|
"Another world is not only possible, she is on her way. On a quiet day, I can hear her breathing." Arundhati Roy, Porto Alegre, Brazil, Jan 27 2003
|
Kim Bax
Daily Musings . . . |
|
|
Fri Sept 7 - Press release, Liberal Candidate Bans Climate Film Liberal candidate Wendy Creighton in a lather about Press Release Thurs Sept 6 - I'm going to the Federal candidates Forum tonight (Forde), on Tamborine Mountain. Here's the four pages of questions & key facts I'm printing out on Australia & Climate Change, and circulating to all of the candidates, audience and press Tues Sept 4 - I got a wonderful email to-day about building bridges of understanding on Climate Change with my local Liberal candidate Wendy Creighton, and they're soooo right. But I replied with my normal biting honesty . . . Mon Sept 3 2007 - Forde Liberal Party candidate Wendy Creighton still refuses to talk one-on-one with a local resident on climate change . . . her further email to me of to-day, and my reply. Sun Sept 2 2007 - Forde Liberal Party candidate Wendy Creighton refuses to take part in a local You-Tube video project on Climate Change . . . Questions to my local Federal candidates on climate change Wed Aug 29 2007 - Went to a key Climate Change conference in Brisbane (Parliament House), and also managed to speak face to face to both the Green and Labour candidates (Forde), re doing a You-Tube interview on the subject Tues Aug 28 2007 - Email to my local Liberal Party candidate on climate change Mon Aug 27 2007 - Someone once described me as a "Gadfly" (affectionately), re my ability to keep buzzing round and annoying the-powers-that-be on various issues - so here's my latest pointed missive on climate change (following up on Friday) . . . Fri Aug 24 2007:- My "Letter to the Editor" on Howard & Climate Change My email & invitation to my local Federal candidates (Forde), re interviews on climate change Local press release (Forde electorate, Qld), re a local Climate Change project/film National Party candidate speaks about Climate on You Tube
|
Fri Sept 7 TOP Press release - Liberal Candidate Bans Climate Film Liberal candidate for Forde Wendy Creighton banned local Cedar Vale mum Kim Bax from filming her reply to some key questions on Climate Change at a local candidates forum on Tamborine Mountain. "None of the other candidates had a problem," said Kim, "just Wendy, it's a disgrace." Kim is not a member of any political party, and has a history of community campaigns, particularly her fight for school bus seatbelts, when she bluntly criticised the State ALP. "I'm not fussy," she said, "I'll speak my mind to any politician, I expect them all to be accountable." Brett Raguse for Labour, Hajnal Ban for the Nationals and Andy Grodecki for the Greens had all previously agreed to answer Kim's pointed questions on climate in privately filmed interviews, but Wendy refused that too. "It's a great project" Kim said, "I'm going to film local people as well, ask them what they think, then post the results to the web. Not everyone can speak to candidates, and Climate's a crucial issue." Kim's also disappointed Wendy reneged on her public promise to send her answers by email when she got home after the Forum. "I've had nothing" Kim said, "maybe my questions are too hard for her." Kim wants to know:-
. . . and, Kim added, those facts were gleaned from senior Liberal Party member Guy Pearse, in his new book "High and Dry," and not from some far-out partisan publication. Liberal candidate Wendy Creighton in a lather about Press Release From Wendy, to Kim (10.43am, Fri 7th Sept), with an added link (opens in a new window), to the answers she sent me:- TOP
Reply from Kim to Wendy (sent at 11.10am, Fri 7 Sept):-
Further reply from Wendy to Kim (sent 11.13am, Fri 7 Sept):-
The email was sent last night as promised, it did not bounce back nor was any error message received. I trust your apology will be as widespread as your criticism. Kim replies again to Wendy:-
Liberal candidate Wendy Creighton calls my Community Climate Film Project a "Home video," denies "Banning" me, refuses to explain further and accuses me of failing to correct the record . . . Her email to me of Friday 7th Sept 2007, followed by my reply TOP
And here's my reply:-
I'm going to the Federal candidates Forum tonight (Forde), on Tamborine Mountain. Here's the four pages of questions & key facts I'm printing out on Australia & Climate Change, and circulating to all of the candidates, audience and press (links open in new pages):- Tues Sept 4 TOP I got a wonderful email to-day about building bridges of understanding on Climate Change with my local Liberal candidate Wendy Creighton - and they're soooo right. But I replied with my normal biting honesty . . . Here's the email (followed by my reply):-
And here's my reply:-
Just sent this pithy 145-word "Letter to the Editor" to 100's of local papers round Australia on APEC & Cimate Change, plus I emailed it to all the State & Federal pollies in Queensland, telling them that . . . TOP "So little Johnny’s still tagging behind big George at APEC, just like he’s always tagged behind The Shrub and his fossil fuel mates. And desperate to score points on Climate, they chorus on about China and India, when Australia (and the US), spills over four times as much CO2 per person. My Gran always said the proof of the pudding was in the eating, so try this one. Here, the sunniest nation on earth, solar power only saves 476,000 tonnes of CO2 a year, that’s 0.28% of the 170 million tonnes spewed from coal. And Johnny’s spruiked $2.8 billion for Climate? That’s over 25 years, while he pork barrels fossil fuel by $8.9 billion a year. And the Chinese? They’re adding 60 gigawatts of renewable power by 2030. That’s more voltage than our entire country uses. So come on Johnnie, get real. Aussies aren’t stupid." TOP Mon Sept 3 2007 TOP Forde Liberal Party candidate Wendy Creighton still refuses to talk one-on-one with a local resident on climate change . . . her further email to me of to-day, and my reply. From Wendy Creighton, to Kim Bax:- "Dear Kim Once again, I believe you’ve mis-interpreted what I’ve said. I am not accusing you of political bias, nor any I “whinging about unfairness”. I simply respect the fact that you have very different views to mine on how to meet the challenge of climate change - and I know there would be little I could do by way of explanation to change them. That’s OK. As I said, I respect that. I hope you will respect my choice not to participate in your You Tube project. I am happy to outline Howard Government policy directly to local residents – indeed that’s what I’m doing on a daily basis. I am accepting every invitation I get to talk directly to local residents on this and other important issues. I look forward to meeting you at Tamborine Mountain on Thursday. Kind regards Wendy" And Kim Bax's reply:-
Sun Sept 2 2007 TOP Forde Liberal Party candidate Wendy Creighton refuses to take part in a local You-Tube video project on Climate Change . . . Here's an email I got from Wendy on Saturday 1st Sept 2007, about my invitation (followed by my reply):-
"Hello Kim
Thanks for the invitation to do a You
Tube interview on climate change. I appreciate this is an issue
about which you care very passionately.
I'd point out that the figures in Guy
Pearse's book are very much out of date as they don't include the
major initiatives the Prime Minister has announced this year on
Climate Change. I'd be happy to send you some very detailed
information on these positive initiatives.
Our policy is to take a practical,
balanced approach to addressing the challenges of climate change -
and, most importantly, to work with other nations to ensure that we
have a global approach to these issues.
I do look forward to meeting you Kim
and I'd welcome the chance to have a one-on-one discussion on these
and other important issues. At this point though, I'll politely
decline the You Tube interview thanks.
I get the impression that anything I
say to defend or explain government policy will simply be regarded
as "spin". As I said, I do understand that you feel strongly on
this issue.
Thanks and I hope we get the chance
to catch up soon.
Kind regards
Wendy"
And here's my reply:-
Well, hating to be unfair to my local Federal candidates (and give them any unexpected surprises), here are the 6 key questions I've sent them to-day on Climate Change - and it's what I'll be asking them in my You-Tube interview . . . (or in the case of Wendy Creighton, Liberal, at the candidates forum on Tamborine Mountain, because she's refused to take part in a one-on-one interview, despite a flexible and open-ended invitation) :- TOP 1. It's agreed that a 60% cut in Global greenhouse gases by 2050 is the absolute minimum to avoid catastrophic climate change (though many expert voices say even this is wildly low). And if you Google:- 60% emissions cut 2050 . . . you'll get hit in the face by the awesome evidence for that. And as, per capita, Aussies emit more CO2 than any other nation (making our example to the World crucial), by what amount do your party's policies aim to reduce our emissions by then, and can you point me in the direction of the independent, scientifically peer-reviewed evidence for that? 2. Have you heard of "Climate Tipping Points," and can I have your comments on this extremely dangerous phenomenon? And here's a clue, Google:- climate tipping points 3. Here's a quote from Wendy Creighton, Liberal candidate for Forde "The new climate change measures announced in this Budget take the Australian Government’s investment in climate change to $2.8 billion." Is it true that that this $2.8 billion will be spent over 25 years, and do you think it's potentially misleading not to mention that? 4. Sydney University estimates Australia spends around $8.9 billion dollars a year subsidising fossil fuels (which certainly puts spending $2.8 billion over 25 years on climate change into perspective). Here's their paper:- http://www.isf.uts.edu.au/publications/CR_2003_paper.pdf What's your response to that? 5. John Howard's new "Solar Cities Programme" (and Australia's only solar powered electricity station at Mildura), will offset about 476,000 tons of CO2 a year - as shown by this Government press release (April 2007), re "Solar Cities":- http://www.environment.gov.au/minister/env/2007/pubs/mr16apr07.pdf . . . and this ABC Lateline programme, re the Mildura Power Station (Oct 2006, quoting Peter Costello):- http://www.abc.net.au/lateline/content/2006/s1773703.htm Whereas Australia's coal powered electricity stations produce about 170 million tonnes of CO2 a year:- http://www.wwf.org.au/news/n23/ . . . which means all of the CO2 saved by Australia's Solar Power (added up), only equals 0.28% of the CO2 spewed by coal in this country. What's your response to that? 6. The Chinese plan to install 60 gigawatts of renewable energy by 2030:- "According to Li, China's goal to develop renewable energy is to increase its installed renewable energy generating capacity to 60 gigawatts by 2010, about 10 percent of the total power capacity, and 121 gigawatts by 2020, 12 percent of the total." http://www.china.org.cn/english/2004/Oct/110012.htm . . . and 60 gigawatts is more than Australia's entire electricity output. Do you think that proves you can run a modern economy on renewables? Wed Aug 29 2007 TOP Went to a key Climate Change conference in Brisbane (Parliament House), and also managed to speak face to face to both the Green and Labour candidates (Forde), re doing a You-Tube interview on the subject Well, it's been a long day. Left home at 6.15am to go to this Climate Change conference, and got home just after 8pm. This morning, I drove to my nearest train stop (about 25 minutes away, Loganlea), and caught the 7am to Brisbane. And who should I bump into at the Station? Brett Raguse ALP candidate for Forde, on the campaign trail. So I said "Hi," and we chatted for a bit. Luckily, I happened to have a copy of Guy Pearse's "High and Dry" on me (an insiders view of Liberal Party spin on Climate Change), so I showed it to him. Brett seemed quite interested in some key facts - like Howard plans to spend $2.8 billion on Climate Change over 25 years, while spending $8 billion a year on the fossil fuel industry, at that it would take 30 Mildura Solar Power Stations to replace even one of our coal fired power ones (of which Australia has 26) - and further, China plans to have 60 gigawats of renewable energy in place by 2030 (more than all of Australia's current electricity production), while Howard's saying you can't run a modern economy on green power. Here's a link to those vital facts (plus more). Let's just say Brett's interest was piqued, and those key (and shocking), stats certainly raised his eyebrows. So I also reminded him about my invitation to do a You-Tube interview on Climate Change, and got a promise he'd get back to me soon . . . So come on Brett. Then who should I bump into at the aforementioned Climate Change Conference? Andy Grodecki, Green candidate for Forde. We had a long and pleasant chat, and I mentioned my accidental meeting with Brett Raguse earlier in the morning - and that I hadn't heard from Wendy Creighton (Liberal candidate), re my You Tube "Climate Change" invite (sent to all my local Federal hopefuls). Anyway, Andy mentioned there's a local candidates forum on Tamborine Mountain very soon, so I suppose I could remind Wendy face to face (if I still haven't heard). Andy also said he'd sent me this email accepting my invitation (which I opened when I got home):- Hi Kim I confirmed with you in our phone discussion on Monday that I happy to be interviewed. I have heavy commitments this week including participation in the 'Leading for the Future - Business and community leaders preparing for the long haul on climate change' Roundtable at Parliament House today, a forum on developing a national strategy for Ecosystem Services on Thursday and a workshop to decide on how to establish a framework for restoring the health of the Logan and Albert (and Lockyer and Bremer) Rivers on Friday. The Greens have been leading on Climate Change for over a decade - we have been reading the reports and listening to the environmental economists and climate scientists and other experts and it has only been the Greens that have pressed for the re-adoption of MRETs and the introduction of other effective low-cost proven already existing technologies and policy solutions for many years. If you were to examine Hansard (the Parliamentary record) you would see the strong stance Bob Brown and the other Senators have taken on this most pressing of issues. I suggest you and your visitors Google 'Re-energising Australia' for the Greens' very comprehensive policy position and examination of the immense opportunities for Australia if we adopt the solutions advocated in the report. I will examine my calendar for next week and contact you to arrange a suitable time. Regards Andy Grodecki from Gleneagle near Beaudesert. I pay respect to the Mulunjali people, their ongoing culture and enduring homelands. Email to my local Liberal Party candidate on climate change TOP Date: 28/08/2007 11:28:59 AM To: campaign@wendycreighton.com.au Subject: Fw: To Mark, from Kim Bax (Climate) From Kim Bax, to Wendy Creighton. I've just spoken to Mark Flack (Albert & Logan News), as detailed below - and also below, is my follow-up email to him. Hope it's of interest. I also rang "The Jimboomba Times" this morning, but both the journalists were out and I left a message for them. I'll also be on the blower to-day to The Tamborine Times, and the Boonah & Fassifern Guardian. Further, here's a hypothetical "Letter to the Editor" that could very well be written about Co-alition climate policies:- "Liberal hopeful Wendy Creighton says Howard’s spending $2.8 billion on global warming, but she doesn’t say that’s over 25 years, and he spends $8 billion in just one year backing fossil fuels. Neither does she admit he’s spending 11 times more on Iraq than on climate change adaptation (remember the New Orleans levees? I guess John’s following George’s example), and $6 billion on 24 new fighter bombers (are they good at filling dams?). And of the funds tagged for Howard’s “Greenhouse Programme,” 81% has gone to fossil fuel companies. Further, Howard’s much vaunted “Solar Cities Programme” needs to be 30 times bigger than it is to offset the carbon from even one of our 26 coal fired power stations. And while Howard claims you can’t run a modern economy on renewables, the Chinese will have over 60 Gigawatts a year coming from biomass and wind by 2030. This is more than all of our coal fired power stations put together. But Wendy, I don’t want to be unfair. All these figures come from Guy Pearse, who joined the Liberals in 1989 and has worked at quite senior levels since (though I guess his career's crimped now, after putting Planet before party). Obviously, you can reply in the press, but I’m also happy to publish you (in full), at www.kimspages.org/wendy.htm I’d love to see you shoot me down in flames via peer reviewed science (not funded by the fossil fuel industry). I’m waiting." But personally Wendy, I don't see these issues as the least bit "Political." As you know, I've never been a member of any formal group - and when I applied to join the ALP, they sent back my money. Rather, the Co-alition's current path (in my view), represents the capture of of the Party by very narrow interests (and a reading of Guy Pearse's book should give you a deeper insight into that) - and their heavily lobbied interests are in direct conflict with the broader business community, and the broader Australian population. There's nothing inherently anti-business and anti-freedom in a clean, green renewable future (you know, a real one - not a conveniently spun mirage of one). All the best, Kim -------Original Message------- From: Date: 28/08/2007 10:49:22 AM Subject: To Mark, from Kim Bax (Climate) To Mark Flack, journalist, Albert & Logan News - from Mrs. Kim Bax (Cedar Vale, Forde electorate) Hi there Mark, Just spoke to you on the phone. Here's me:- Here's my invitation to all our local candidates re a "You Tube" interview on climate change:- http://www.kimspages.org/dailymusings.htm#emailforde Here's my press release about it (short and pithy):- http://www.kimspages.org/dailymusings.htm#pressrelease24aug Here's Hajnal Ban's immediate acceptance:- http://www.kimspages.org/dailymusings.htm#hajnal Further, here's some of the KEY facts from Guy Pearse's new book that I'll be asking them about: http://www.highanddry.com.au/stats.cfm http://www.highanddry.com.au/didyouknow.cfm All the best, Kim PS - and as I also said on the phone, I'll be out and about asking local people (all over the electorate), for their views - and posting the footage on-line Phone 5543 1796 or 041 270 8451 TOPMon Aug 27 2007:- TOP
From:-
Mrs. Kim Bax, 77 Orion Road, Cedar Vale, Qld 4285 My "Letter to the Editor" on Howard & Climate Change TOP Went late night shopping (Garden City, Mount Gravatt), with hubby and daughter yesterday. I spent most of my time in Borders Bookshop (after getting my eyebrows waxed and tinted that is), and picked up a copy of a brand new book on John Howard's response to climate change by a Liberal Party insider (Guy Pearse), called "High & Dry." So far I'm up to page 149, but it's already prompted me to send this email to every politician (State & Federal), in Queensland HERE (opens in a new window), with my short (92 word), sharp "Letter to the Editor" (which editor you might ask? Several hundred local ones, all over Australia . . . ). TOP My email & invitation to my local Federal candidates (Forde), re interviews on climate change TOP Invitation to Hajnal Ban (National), Wendy Creighton (Liberal), Andy Grodecki (Green) and Brett Raguse (ALP), re local "You Tube" interviews - (Federal candidates for Forde, Qld) Re:- Climate Change policy cc - Federal & State politicians (Qld), plus Peter Garrett - plus various email lists all over Australia to spread the initiative From Mrs Kim Bax (Cedar Vale, Beaudesert Shire) Dear Brett, Hajnal, Wendy and Andy, I've met each of you at some point (except Wendy), and you know my family and I are long term residents of the area. Yesterday I picked up a new book at Borders in Mount Gravatt, "High & Dry" by Liberal Party insider Guy Pearse, about John Howard and climate change. I'm already a third of the way through, and horrified by what he's written. He says to avoid disaster, we need to reduce greenhouse emissions 60% by 2050, but Howard's trajectory will cause a 70% increase by then. I personally know that the 60% figure is about right (if not more), as I had the honour of speaking one-on-one to leading climate scientist Dr. Graeme Pearman at The Ethos Foundation (Binna Burra, Beaudesert Shire), earlier this year. I also heard first hand about Dr. Pearman's experience of working under a Howard Government, some of which is documented by Guy Pearse in his book. Over the next 4 weeks or so I and a few other non-aligned local people will be out and about interviewing other local people re their thoughts on climate change, and with their permission, posting the results on You-Tube. We will also be liaising with all the local press in Forde about this project. When will you be available to add your voices (and interview), to this fascinating project? My time is flexible, just let me know what would be convenient. I also think it would be helpful if you could make the time to read Guy Pearse's crucial work in the interim. The website is www.highanddry.com.au And Brett, I would also expect a definitive answer from you on the ALP's "Mandatory Renewable Energy Targets," and it's certainly one of the questions I'll be asking. I rang Peter Garrett's office this morning, and got this email in reply:- "Hi Kim, Thanks for your call earlier. I'm sorry I couldn't give you an answer off the top of my head. I actually wasn't sure if we had set one. Unfortunately I still do not have an exact number to give you, because all the ALP has said is that it will be "significally increased". However, I can assure you that in the lead up to the election a percentage will be released, so keep your eyes pealed! Hope that helps. Cheers" And then after a Google search, I found these excerpts from an interview with Peter Garrett from almost 3 months ago:- DAVID MARK: Labor's
climate change and the environment spokesman, Peter Garrett, wants the
MRETs scheme maintained and expanded, but he's not saying by how much. http://www.abc.net.au/pm/content/2007/s1943218.htm Hope to get answers to my invitation soon. Very best wishes, Kim TOP Local press release (Forde electorate, Qld), re a local Climate Change project/film TOP Forde Mum puts our pollies on the spot about Global Warming Local mum Kim Bax is stunned by the revelations of Liberal Party insider Guy Pearse in his new book "High & Dry." "I was shocked," she says, "he writes that we need to reduce emissions 60% by 2050 to avoid disaster, but Howard's on track to increase them by 70%. So severely rattled, I rang Peter Garrett's office to find out how much renewable energy the ALP plans to put in place, and found they don't know. It's a joke, our politicians are taking us for a ride." But now Kim's determined to put all of them on the spot with a film project asking local people (and local candidates) for their opinion, and posting the results on line. "You Tube is fast becoming the people's media" she said, "it's a way for everyone to have a say. Maybe we can have home-grown Michael Moore's popping up all over the place. I've already sent all our local candidates an open-ended invitation." TOP National Party candidate speaks about Climate on You Tube TOP National Party candidate for Forde, Hajnal Ban, agrees to a You Tube interview on Climate Change:-
"Hello Kim,
How about Friday 7th September say 3pm? It's a few weeks away but that will give me time to read "High & Dry". How does that suit you? Hajnal" And my reply:-
"Thanks for that Hajnal - you're
an absolute gem. Yes, that would be fine. Thank you so
much. :-)
|
Home
|